COSTS & CONTRACTS

Consumption changes.
What does your contract say?

Forecast quantity, tolerance and billing: This is how companies check how an electricity offer handles higher or lower consumption.

Read article ↓All articles →
Below plan: lower consumption — read the terms; within the band: check the agreed tolerance; above plan: higher consumption — check the pricing formula.
QUANTITY RISK
  1. Below planLower consumption: read the terms
  2. In the bandCheck agreed tolerance
  3. Above planHigher consumption: check the pricing formula
OPTUM / PRACTICEVOLUME RISK

What a volume tolerance band defines

A company plans for a certain volume of electricity. Actual consumption may differ because of changed orders, new equipment or a longer shutdown. A volume tolerance band defines an agreed range around the planned volume, with a lower and an upper limit, for example. It is part of the rules governing how the supplier handles deviations. The contract terms specify whether the agreed price applies within the band and how volumes outside it are billed.

There is no volume tolerance band that automatically applies to every business offer. Some offers include tolerances, others have separate rules or a different pricing model. The term “full supply” alone also does not tell you whether higher or lower volumes are covered without extra costs. Ask the supplier to explain the financial consequences of a deviation using an example.

First, clarify the reference point.

  • Period: Is the deviation assessed per year, month, or over the entire period?
  • Scope: Does the quantity apply per delivery point or to the joint portfolio?
  • Initial value: Is the forecast fixed or adjustable according to a defined procedure?
  • Boundary: Is only the volume outside the tolerance settled separately, or a larger difference in volume?

Two percentages are comparable only if they use the same reference basis. Across multiple sites, a shared tolerance band can work differently from separate bands for each site. The offer should explain this clearly.

Editorial illustration: the volume tolerance band sets a contractual framework. The pricing rules determine the costs outside it.
The volume tolerance band sets a contractual framework. The pricing rules determine the costs outside it.
AT A GLANCE

A volume tolerance band is unclear without its reference basis

PERIODYear, month, or duration?

When is a deviation determined?

SCOPEDelivery point or portfolio.

Which quantities are considered together?

RULELimit and price formula?

How are deviations settled?

These three pieces of information belong together. A percentage value alone does not describe the economic impact.

A numerical example to aid understanding

Assuming the agreed annual quantity is 1,000,000 kWh, a band of ±10 percent chosen solely for explanation purposes would then range from 900,000 to 1,100,000 kWh.

  • Excess consumption: At 1,150,000 kWh, 50,000 kWh are above the upper limit. However, compared to the planned amount, the excess consumption is 150,000 kWh.
  • Reduced consumption: At 850,000 kWh, this is 50,000 kWh below the limit and 150,000 kWh less than planned.

The contract must clearly state which of these differences counts for billing purposes.

The tolerance band does not determine the price.

No surcharge or credit can be calculated based solely on the 50,000 kWh. The contractual billing formula and the relevant prices are missing.

The figures do not represent standard market tolerances or OPTUM's terms of offer. They illustrate why quantity specifications and pricing must be reviewed together. Furthermore, identical percentage limits for both upper and lower limits do not imply that over- and under-consumption will be billed using the same pricing formula.

Consider changes before finalizing the contract

An additional production line or a new charging system changes more than the annual electricity volume. Its distribution over time can also change. Check which changes are already included in the forecast and how later adjustments should be reported.

For self-generation, the remaining amount of electricity purchased is relevant. Only the solar power that the business can actually use itself can be deducted from the previous grid consumption. Surpluses fed into the grid do not replace later electricity purchases. Therefore, for accurate forecasting, generation and consumption must align in time. See also article Photovoltaics, Storage and Residual Electricity Contract .

Four answers before the decision

Have the delivery quantity, how deviations will be detected, the applicable formula, and your reporting options explained to you in writing. Additionally, ask when planned changes must be reported and whether these changes will affect prices or other terms. Document the answers along with the relevant section of the contract.

For comparison purposes, you can provide all suppliers with the same three consumption scenarios: less, as planned, and more. Ideally, the quantities should come from your operational planning. This way, you compare the economic consequences on the same basis, instead of solely determining the cheapest offer based on the price per unit.

Discuss quantity planning and procurement requirements with OPTUM: Specify the expected annual quantity and any foreseeable changes. We will clarify the framework for further bid evaluation with you.

AT A GLANCE

From actual consumption to billing

  1. 01Determine consumption

    Determine the actual quantity for the agreed period.

  2. 02Check the purchased quantity

    Compare with the contractual forecast and tolerances.

  3. 03Apply price rule

    Check the handling of deviations as agreed in the contract.

A volume tolerance band is not a general promise that higher or lower consumption is covered without extra costs. The specific contract rules determine this.
SUITABLE FOR YOUR QUESTION

Delve deeper into what will move you forward.

Preparing Energy Tenders: Documents for CompaniesWhat information suppliers need for a comparable electricity or gas offer – and how to avoid queries before the tender.
Read more →
Understanding Procurement Models: Fixed Price, Tranches & SpotCorrectly distinguishing between fixed price, tranches, spot market and full supply: Price risks, planning, comparison and transparent price scenarios for companies.
Read more →
SHARING KNOWLEDGE

CLARITY BEFORE SIGNING

You know the terms and conditions.
Before you sign.

We work with you to develop a solution tailored to your business, goals, and security needs. You'll receive our vetted recommendation, complete with comprehensive data and concrete offers. You'll see which price components are fixed, which are variable, and the criteria we use to select suppliers. We document all agreements with you in a transparent and easily understandable manner.

Discuss procurement

OPTUM in the community

What would you like to know?

Enter a term or choose an entry point.

No registration required. The search remains in your browser.